![]() | You are viewing Log in Create a LiveJournal Account Learn more | Explore LJ: Life Entertainment Music Culture News & Politics Technology |
| S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | 31 |
Okay, I know people on Youtube are idiots. I know they are. But I am so deeply horrified by this conversation on so many levels, I can't even express it.
First of all, "although black"? What the hell? All black people are incapable of speaking correctly? Is that it?
And the second person? "He gets his speaking skills from the white half?"
Speech has NOTHING to do with race. It's not like white people are born speaking one way and black people are born speaking another. If you want to stereotype, black people more frequently speak a different dialect of English than white people. But no one's dialect or language is implanted in their brains from birth. It's not genetic. Children learn the language and dialect of the place they grow up. A native "black" speaker, someone who grew up speaking AAVE (African American Vernacular English, and I may date myself by using the expression, as I hear the term African American has been given way to in favor of simply "black", but this was what it was called in my linguistics book. It's hard to keep up with political correctness.) can learn Standard English (the "white" dialect, the one taught in schools) just as easily as a "white" or Standard English speaker could learn AAVE (probably more easily, in fact, as there are aspects of AAVE, like any dialect, that would be hard to pick up without a diction class or something of the like, and of course they're not offered.)
Not all black people speak AAVE, just as not all white people speak Standard English. That right there is a stereotype in and of itself.
In addition, there is no intrinsic reason why Standard English is better than AAVE. Both are grammatically sound and intelligible. There's a fuckton of political and economic reasons why Standard English won out, not the least of which is that is, in fact, more standard and therefore more universally intelligible. There's also some nasty stuff about slavery and racism, but I don't think I've made enough of a study of the history of AAVE to go on a diatribe about that, so. I'm just saying. Standard English is not a better language than AAVE, any more than Latin is a better language than French, or Chinese is a better language than Japanese. Those may in fact be false comparisons as AAVE is a dialect, an offshoot or cousin of English rather than another language altogether (though many linguists have made the case that AAVE shares similarities with West African languages and is in fact a creole), but fine. French French is not a better language than Canadian French. You get my drift. Many words commonly recognized as Standard English today came from AAVE, such as "hip" and "cool." How many times a day do you use the word cool?
And no. I'm not saying we should teach AAVE, any more than we should teach 133t in schools, because it would be a pain in the ass, and the fact of the matter is, Standard English is the prestige dialect. If you want to be taken seriously, you have to speak "proper" Standard English. Don't get me wrong. I love English. I'm a bit of a grammar freak (Though obviously not that hardcore, as you can see by the mistakes in this blog). I just wish people would stop being assholes and realize that they're not better than anyone just because they speak a certain dialect of English. Languages are all connected. There are not hard lines dividing them from one another. It may seem that way; French and English are different, but they share many cognates and have a common sentence structure. And they both borrow words back and forth. Fiancee. Bouquet. Prairie. Languages are always changing, adding and dropping words, melding and splitting.
My point: People of the world, stop being idiot racist linguistic snob assholes. Mmmkay?